Skip to main content

Russian Public Helped Free 1 'Moscow Case' Prisoner, Now They Want More

Their voices are getting louder and they will be hard to silence

Published in: The Moscow Times
Pavel Ustinov. Screenshot from his page on the website created in August 2019 to mobilize support for those jailed over the protests in Moscow. © Accessed September 20, 2019.

Today, the Moscow city court released Pavel Ustinov from jail. The 24-year-old actor was sentenced to 3.5 years in prison on September 16, on far-fetched police assault charges. His is one of a dozen unjustified prosecutions in the so-called “Moscow Case,” brought in retaliation for election-related protests this summer. 

Ustinov’s appeal hearing is scheduled for Sept. 26, but his release from custody — on his own recognizance — pending appeal could signal that the appeal will yield a suspended sentence. Ustinov’s release was requested by the very same prosecutors who just days earlier demanded a six-year prison term and seemed barely satisfied with the lesser sentence handed down by the judge. The authorities’ apparent change of heart was almost unprecedented and inspires hope for other victims of politically motivated prosecutions.

In mid-July, the disqualification of viable opposition candidates from the September 8 Moscow legislative assembly elections sparked sustained, unauthorized, but peaceful gatherings in Russia’s capital. The authorities responded with an overwhelming show of force. Police used excessive force against protesters, dozens of whom were injured, and arrested record numbers of demonstrators and random bystanders — close to 1,400 on July 27 alone. 

Apparently aiming to further discourage protests, the authorities also opened several major criminal investigations. Eighteen people were arrested on charges of “mass rioting” and/or assaulting the police. Video footage showed that some of the accused did not engage in any aggressive behavior and others threw empty plastic bottles and the like. By mid-September, five of them, including Ustinov, had been sentenced, for assault, to two-to three-and-a-half years in prison, and one, Konstantin Kotov, received a draconian four-year prison sentence merely for repeated participation in unsanctioned public gatherings.

Ustinov was, in fact, a bystander. The charges against him stemmed from the allegations that on Aug. 3, at around 3:30 p.m., he “shouted slogans offensive to the authorities,” then resisted arrest and dislocated the left shoulder of a Russian National Guard officer. Ustinov insisted however, that he did not take part in the protest and wasn’t even aware a protest was going on. He was simply waiting for an acquaintance right next to the entrance to the metro station on Pushkin Square, a common meeting place for Muscovites in the city center. 

Video footage from several different sources, including TV Rain, shows Ustinov standing quietly, glued to the screen of his cell-phone, when a group of Russian Guard — Russia’s national guard — officers suddenly jumped him, tackled him to the ground, and beat him with batons. 

By the time Ustinov received this hefty sentence for his offense of standing on a square and getting trampled, the “Moscow Case” had already spurred a widespread “Freedom for Political Prisoners” campaign. His predicament, however, became the tipping point – possibly for the very reason that he had nothing to do with the actual protests.

It showed with absolute clarity that the authorities can no longer keep their end of the unspoken bargain they had struck years ago with the mainstream public — "stay out of politics and you’ll be safe.” Ustinov had nothing to do with politics. He should have been safe. 

But the repressive machinery has taken on a life of its own and crushes the apolitical together with the dissenters. 

Famous theater personalities, A-list pop-stars, and other prominent figures, including those who never showed anything but loyalty vis-à-vis the Kremlin, spoke up in his defense and called for his release. A wave of public indignation was rising by the hour, leaving the authorities no choice but to set him free.

However, by then, numerous petitions and open letters by various groups — academics, priests, artists, teachers, medical professionals, lawyers, publishers students — demanding freedom for those still jailed under the “Moscow Case” and an end to politically motivated prosecutions began circulating and gaining increasing numbers of signatures and attention. 

Their voices are getting louder and they will not be silenced.

Your tax deductible gift can help stop human rights violations and save lives around the world.

Region / Country