WATCH Human Rights News PortuguesFrancaisRussianGerman
EspanolChineseArabicOther Languages

UN: Rights Council Disappoints Again

Fails to Take Action on Darfur, Sri Lanka and Uzbekistan

(Geneva, October 6, 2006) – The UN Human Rights Council adjourned its second regular session today without taking any effective action to address the world’s human rights crises, Human Rights Watch said today. States with poor human rights records dominated the council’s deliberations and countries more committed to human rights failed to exercise effective leadership.

" The council showed that it is not yet up to the challenge of objectively assessing rights abuses and taking concrete action to address them. It lacked both vision and resolve at this session. A course change is urgently needed if this new body is to get on track. "
Peggy Hicks, Global Advocacy Director

Related Material

Human Rights Council: New Approaches to Addressing Human Rights Situations
Background Briefing, September 15, 2006

UN: Rights Council Misses Opportunity on Uzbekistan
Press Release, October 3, 2006

UN: States Must Cooperate With Human Rights Council
Press Release, September 29, 2006

Universal Periodic Review
Background Briefing, August 18, 2006

Human Rights Council: No More Business as Usual
Background Briefing, May 19, 2006

More of Human Rights Watch's work on the Israel - Lebanon Conflict
Thematic Page, October 6, 2006

“In the face of atrocities in the Sudan, attacks on civilians in Sri Lanka, and impunity for mass murder in Uzbekistan, this council was largely silent,” said Peggy Hicks, global advocacy director of Human Rights Watch. “As the premier international human rights body, the council needs to demonstrate its credibility by taking robust action against violator states.”  
The council heard detailed reporting from its independent experts on human rights violations in a number of countries during its “interactive dialogue” segment, but was not able to agree on any follow-up to their findings.  
The council also adopted only a short procedural decision allowing continuation of its activities, and will meet again in late November to continue its work.  
The council postponed consideration of all resolutions presented during this session, including two on Darfur, despite Sudan’s responsibility for ongoing war crimes and its continuing defiance of UN Security Council resolutions when African states and the European Union could not agree on a text. It also failed to act on a proposal by the European Union to address the deteriorating situation in Sri Lanka because of strong opposition from the Organization of the Islamic Conference (OIC) and a number of Asian states.  
Four of the independent experts appointed by the council, after a fact-finding mission to Lebanon and Israel, found serious violations of human rights and humanitarian law by Israel and Hezbollah during the recent conflict, in line with findings by Human Rights Watch. The council’s discussion of their report, however, largely ignored these findings. Numerous Arab and Muslim states denounced the report as biased towards Israel, while Israel faulted the report for failing to discuss Lebanon’s role in the crisis. The debate demonstrated the council’s continuing inability to objectively address the responsibilities under international law of all parties to the conflict in Lebanon, Human Rights Watch said.  
Despite the Uzbek government’s abusive crackdown following the massacre of hundreds of unarmed protesters in Andijan in May 2005, the council also refused to publicly address the human rights situation in Uzbekistan, deciding instead to continue to examine the situation in private.  
The Human Rights Council, which was established in June 2006, is struggling to distinguish itself from its discredited predecessor, the Commission on Human Rights. Human Rights Watch has proposed that the council adopt a new process for handling human rights situations, with a full range of responses to abuses, ranging from assistance for human rights programs to measures designed to compel changes where cooperation fails.  
At this session, the council continued work relating to establishment of a “universal periodic review” under which the human rights records all UN member states will be examined. The UN General Assembly resolution that created the council requires that this system be in place within a year.  
One bright note at this session was the broad participation of non-governmental organizations, including those from countries where there are widespread human rights violations.  
As in the previous session, a number of states with poor human rights records played an active and particularly troubling role in the council’s deliberations. Discussions were frequently dominated by abusive governments, and decisions gravitated towards the lowest common denominator in order to achieve consensus. States with stronger records on human rights, including many that have emerged recently from periods of substantial abuses, were on the defensive. These states were frequently outflanked by the spoilers, who seemed able to act both more cohesively and more strategically. If the council is to succeed, Human Rights Watch said, human rights supporters will need to elevate their efforts and demonstrate greater leadership.  
“The council showed that it is not yet up to the challenge of objectively assessing rights abuses and taking concrete action to address them. It lacked both vision and resolve at this session,” Hicks said. “A course change is urgently needed if this new body is to get on track.”

Suggest This Page to a Friend
Your Email (Required)
Your Friend's Name (Optional)
Friend's Email (Required)
Your Message (optional)

HRW Privacy Policy

(*) Email addresses are not stored.

Enter Security Code as shown (case sensitive):

HRW Logo Contribute to Human Rights Watch

Home | About Us | News Releases | Publications | Info by Country | Global Issues | Campaigns | What You Can Do | Community | Bookstore | Film Festival | Search | Site Map | Contact Us | Press Contacts | Privacy Policy

© Copyright 2006, Human Rights Watch    350 Fifth Avenue, 34th Floor    New York, NY 10118-3299    USA