August 23, 2011

Ripe with Abuse

Human Rights Conditions in South Africa’s Fruit and Wine Industries

Summary
Key Recommendations
Methodology
I. Understanding South African and Western Cape Agriculture
1.1. Farming in South Africa and the Western Cape
1.2. Farmworkers
Box 1: Increased Vulnerability of Female Farmworkers and Farm Dwellers
1.3. Farm Dwellers and On-Farm Housing
1.4. Farmers, Management, and the Supply Chain
1.5. Previous Scrutiny of Farm Work in South Africa
II. Governmental and Business Responsibilities
2.1. The South African Government’s Constitutional and International Legal Obligations and Relevant Domestic Law that Applies to Employers and Farm Owners
Evictions and Housing Conditions
Occupational Health and Safety
Freedom of Association
Conditions of Employment
Racial and Gender Discrimination
2.2. International Human Rights Responsibilities of Private Actors
III. Poor Housing and Evictions from Farms
3.1. Poor Housing Conditions on Farms
3.2. Evictions
3.3. Related Impact on Right to Family Life
IV. Occupational and Other Health and Safety Issues
4.1. Pesticide Exposure
Failure to Provide Proper Safety Equipment to Workers Working Directly With Pesticides
Failure to Mitigate Pesticide Exposure for People Not Working Directly With Pesticides
4.2. Sanitation and Access to Drinking Water While Working
Toilets and Hand Washing Facilities
Drinking Water
4.3. Injuries While Working
4.4. Legacy of the Dop System..
Box 2: Remnants of the Dop System..
4.5. Failure to Provide Sick Leave or Maternity Leave
Box 3: Challenges Faced by Foreign Migrant Workers in the Western Cape
V. Lack of Freedom of Association and Obstacles to Union Formation
5.1. Obstacles to Union Formation
5.2. Farmers’ Efforts to Force or Persuade People to Resign from Unions
5.3. Poor Treatment of Union Members
5.4. Impact of Union Formation
VI. Protection and Redress
Box 4: The Government’s Failure to Protect Beneficiaries in Farm Equity Schemes
6.1. Lack of Effective Government Monitoring of Labor Conditions and Enforcement of Labor Laws
Labor Inspector Capacity
Labor Inspections and the Agreement Between the Department of Labour and Agri SA
6.2. Failure of the Government to Protect People Evicted from Farms
6.3. Limited Private Efforts to Address Conditions for Farmworkers and Farm Dwellers
Box 5: Better Practices on Farms
Farmers’ Associations
Wine Industry
Fruit Industry
Fairtrade Certification
International and Domestic Retailers
6.4. Conclusion
VII. Detailed Recommendations
Acknowledgements