HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH HOME | SITEMAP | SEARCH | CONTACT | REPORTS | PRESS ARCHIVES
Beijing Spring Turns to Winter FREE    Join the HRW Mailing List 
Document of the Bureau of Supervision, Nanshan District, Shenzhen Municipality
Shen Nan Jian Shen (1997) No. 2

Decision on Disciplinary Action Against Bai Suping for Her Errors

Bai Suping (formerly Chen Zhongling); female; nationality: Han; date of birth: December 1970; place of birth: Lingbao County, Henan Province; education: professional secondary school; was transferred in January 1993 from No. 1 Hospital of Xian Medical College to Xili Hospital in Shenzhen to serve as a nurse.

Related Material

Man Who Exposed Chinese "Blacklist" Ill In Prison
HRW Press Release, April 20, 1999

Shenzhen Municipality Intermediate People's Court, Guangdong Province Ruling in a Criminal Case

In August 1994, Chen Meng, Bai Suping's brother (handled in a separate case), came to Shenzhen from Shaanxi, and stayed temporarily with Bai Suping in her Xili Hospital dormitory. In September 1994, Chen Meng learned that the outside hostile elements in Hong Kong needed a "name list of the June 4 pro-democracy elements barred from entering China," and he got the idea of trying to steal a copy of that "name list." He tried to obtain this list through Tang Tao, Bai Suping's husband (handled in a separate case), then serving in the Sixth Brigade of the People's Armed Police. One evening at the end of October 1994 in Bai Suping's dormitory, he asked Tang Tao whether the latter had seen something like a "name list of people barred from entering China." Tang Tao said he thought he had seen one, and promised to look for it when he returned to the barracks. That same evening, Tang Tao returned to the barracks and found a copy of the A List of 49 Overseas Members of Reactionary Organizations Currently Subject to Major Control (a top secret document) in his office desk drawer. He took the top secret document, returned to Xili, and handed it over to Chen Meng. On November 5, 1994, Chen Meng asked Bai Suping to look for some place near Xili Hospial where he could send a fax. Bai said the Nanyue Company had a fax machine and she knew someone there. Sometime after two o'clock that afternoon, Bai Suping took Chen Meng to Nanyue Pharmaceutical Co. Ltd., found the person she knew and through him sent the top secret document and other documents to Hong Kong. The above facts have been corroborated, the evidence is conclusive and Bai has confessed. Bai Suping, a state cadre, violated state regulations regarding the protection of state secrets, not only did not report promptly to her organization her brother Chen Meng's intention to transmit a top secret state document to Hong Kong and try to stop him, but also actually took active measures to provide facilities to help her brother fax the "name list" out of the country. That resulted in a serious instance of disclosure of secrets, which had an extremely damaging impact on our country in the outside world. When the matter was discovered, the Municipal Public Security Bureau, in view of the fact that Bai Suping's offense was not serious and that she adopted a good attitude by admitting her guilt, and in accordance with the revelant provisions, made the decision in July 1996 on disciplinary action against her: Reeducation Through Labor. In the interests of tightening discipline and educating the person in question, and in accordance with Article 26 of Law of the People's Republic of China on the Protection of State Secrets, Article 30 of the Enforcement of the Law of the People's Republic of China on the Protection of State Secrets, and Chapter 2, Article 4, Section 11 of the Interim Provisions of the City of Shenzhen on Administrative Disciplinary Action, the Conference of Chiefs of the Bureau of Supervision has decided to record a major demerit in the file of Bai Suping.

Bureau of Supervision, Nanshan District, City of Shenzhen (Official seal), August 18, 1997

Subject: Decision on administrative disciplinary action To: Bureau of Health and Xili Hospital of Nanshan District, Bai Suping Report to: Municipal Supervision Adjudication Department Send to : Municipal Personnel Bureau

For Further Information:
HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH HOME | SITEMAP | SEARCH | CONTACT | REPORTS | PRESS ARCHIVES