HUMAN RIGHTS
WATCH Monthly Update PortuguesFrancaisRussianGerman
EspanolChineseArabicOther Languages
   

HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH
MONTHLY EMAIL UPDATE
January 2002

---
IN THIS ISSUE:
> Advocacy After September 11
> US Drops Anti-ICC Law
> UN Studies Violence Against Children Worldwide
> HRW Research Contributes to Arrest of Slovak Arms Dealer
> Congo to Ratify ICC
> December Publications
> Become a Member or Make a Contribution
---


ADVOCACY AFTER SEPTEMBER 11

Human Rights Watch continued to spotlight threats to human rights in the wake of September 11. Over the past month in Pakistan, HRW researchers interviewed hundreds of Afghan refugees to gather information about the situation in the Pakistani refugee camps and the areas recently opened on the Afghan border. Human Rights Watch pressed for the humane treatment of captured foreign fighters and their families and urged the United States and Britain to provide logistical support for the safe surrender, disarming, and detention of captured fighters. HRW also called on the United States and Britain to ensure that Taliban commanders alleged to have committed international crimes be held by an outside independent authority until they can be prosecuted before an impartial tribunal. HRW staff met with senior Pentagon officials in Washington to discuss compliance with international humanitarian law in the use of air power. HRW also participated in a UNIFEM (United Nations Development Fund for Women) conference in Brussels on the role of Afghan women in rebuilding Afghanistan. Find out more at http://www.hrw.org/campaigns/september11

Under President Bush's Military Order on military commissions, any foreign national designated by the President as a suspected terrorist or as aiding terrorists could potentially be arrested, tried, convicted and even executed without a public trial, without adequate access to counsel, without the presumption of innocence or even proof of guilt beyond reasonable doubt, and without the right to judicial appeal. As the US Department of Defense began drafting the rules that will implement the President's order, HRW urged the Defense Department to incorporate provisions consistent with existing legal procedures in the Uniform Code of Military Justice, a reasonable model of fairness and respect for individual rights that, by definition, works for times of war as well as for times of peace. We also pressed for military commissions to be used only for people arrested overseas where U.S. courts are unavailable for war crimes committed in the course of armed conflict.

WHAT YOU CAN DO
News reports have suggested the regulations being drafted may incorporate many of our recommendations, such as public trial and the right to counsel of choice. Until the regulations are final, however, please send letters to Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld urging him to ensure the new military commissions provide defendants with full due process protections and are limited to people overseas accused of war-related abuses. Find out more and take action now at http://www.hrw.org/campaigns/september11/tribunals.htm

Saudi Arabia has long been a key strategic ally of the United States in the Middle East -- as the world's largest oil exporter, as host for some of the most sophisticated military bases available to the United States in the region, and as the largest market in the region for US goods and services, especially arms. This relationship was strained when it was disclosed that fifteen of the nineteen alleged September 11 hijackers were Saudi nationals. US officials have consistently sought to downplay the tension, as they have consistently downplayed the poor human rights record of Saudi Arabia.
     In our widely cited December 19 backgrounder, Human Rights Watch described how decades of disrespect for human rights have distorted political and civic life in Saudi Arabia. The government's violent crackdown on dissent has dangerously narrowed possibilities for peaceful political reform. The backgrounder documents political violence, flaws in the justice system, discrimination against women and the Shi'a Muslim minority, and the use of cruel, inhuman and degrading punishment such as flogging, amputation, and the death penalty.
     Find out more at http://hrw.org/backgrounder/mena/saudi


------
US DROPS ANTI-ICC LAW

On December 7, the US Senate passed Senator Jesse Helms's anti-International Criminal Court proposal, the "American Servicemembers Protection Act" (ASPA), as an amendment to the Defense Appropriations Act. The ASPA attempted to undermine the establishment of a permanent International Criminal Court (ICC), which will prosecute individuals accused of genocide, crimes against humanity, and war crimes when national courts are unable to do so. The ASPA would have prohibited cooperation of any kind with the Court and was characterized by some as "The Hague Invasion Act" because it authorized the United States to use "all means necessary and appropriate" to liberate any US or allied persons detained by the ICC, which will be based in The Hague, The Netherlands.
     Human Rights Watch urged US officials and EU governments to speak out against the ASPA, especially those provisions that prohibit US cooperation with governments that support the ICC. HRW and other organizations also urged their members and the public to write committee members in Congress urging them to remove the anti-ICC provision from the Defense Appropriations Act.
     All the hard work and solidarity paid off: on December 20, the House and Senate dropped the anti-ICC provision when it adopted a final version of the appropriations bill.
     Find out more about the United States and the International Criminal Court at http://hrw.org/campaigns/icc/


------
UN STUDIES VIOLENCE AGAINST CHILDREN WORLDWIDE

The UN General Assembly recently requested an in-depth study on violence against children. Human Rights Watch first proposed the study two years ago, and successfully lobbied both the Committee on the Rights of the Child and UN member states to gain approval. The U.N. study was one of the key recommendations of HRW's October 2001 report "Easy Targets: Violence Against Children Worldwide." The UN study will examine violence against children in their homes, in their schools, on the street, at work, and in custodial institutions, and will recommend government measures to end such violence.

Find out more about HRW's work on children's rights at http://www.hrw.org/children


------
HRW RESEARCH CONTRIBUTES TO ARREST OF SLOVAK ARMS DEALER

Weapons sent to abusive forces in Africa fuel brutal wars and feed regional instability, with terrible consequences for human rights. In March 2001, the United Nations tightened a 1992 arms embargo on Liberia to curb weapons trafficking via that country to Revolutionary United Front rebels in Sierra Leone. HRW's November 15 briefing paper, "No Questions Asked: The Eastern Europe Arms Pipeline to Liberia," reveals that the arms embargo has been flouted with alarming regularity and illustrates the channels through which arms are smuggled. The HRW publication, which drew on detailed findings in a UN report prepared by an independent panel of experts on Liberia, highlighted the role of central and eastern European governments in permitting the illegal trade.
     The HRW briefing paper helped generate pressure for the arrest by Slovak police of Peter Jusko, an arms dealer implicated in the UN report. Jusko was subsequently released on bail while investigations continue. Slovak prosecutors also have opened a case against a general from Kyrgyzstan and a Russian citizen accused of collaborating with Jusko in the illegal export of combat helicopters to Liberia.

Find out more at http://www.hrw.org/press/2001/11/liberialett20.htm
Read the briefing paper at http://www.hrw.org/backgrounder/arms/liberia1115.htm


------
CONGO TO RATIFY ICC

In early December, Human Rights Watch Counsel Pascal Kambale organized a Government-NGO conference on the International Criminal Court (ICC) in Kinshasa in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC). In addition to pressing for the DRC's ratification of the ICC treaty, the conference facilitated the interaction between the Kabila government and the national human rights movement. On December 6, 2001, Minister of Justice Ngele Masudi announced that the DRC would ratify the ICC.

Find out more about human rights in the Democratic Republic of Congo at http://www.hrw.org/africa/congo.php
Find out more about the International Criminal Court at http://www.hrw.org/campaigns/icc/


------
DECEMBER PUBLICATIONS:

ARGENTINA

Argentina's courts have reinvigorated long-stalled prosecutions of the perpetrators of crimes committed under Argentina's military government (1976-1983), but high-level government officials have been reluctant to support this effort.
     On November 9, 2001, the Federal Court of Buenos Aires invalidated the country's longstanding amnesty laws. The court ruled unanimously that the laws, introduced by the government of Raúl Alfonsín in 1986 and 1987 to appease military anger at human rights prosecutions, were unconstitutional and violated international norms.
     On December 12, Human Rights Watch released "Reluctant Partner: The Argentine Government's Failure to Back Trials of Human Rights Violators." The report traces the history of accountability for atrocities that were committed by the military junta and by left- and right-wing factions in the 1970s and early 1980s, when an estimated 15,000 people "disappeared." Due to the amnesty laws, all military officers responsible for torture and "disappearances" have enjoyed immunity from prosecution since 1987. Since then, the armed forces have continued to insist that records relating to the plight of the "disappeared" were destroyed when the junta left power. The government has also refused to extradite such officers to European countries seeking to prosecute crimes committed against their nationals during the "dirty war." The report was covered in Argentina by Pagina 12, La Nacion, and Clarin, and in the United States by The Miami Herald.
     In a December 11 meeting with then President Fernando de la Rua and his Ministers of Justice and the Interior, Human Rights Watch urged the government to support prosecutions for past abuses and to ensure that extradition requests are passed to the Argentine judiciary for investigation.
     The Argentine Supreme Court is expected to hear an appeal next year against the Federal Court ruling that nullified Argentina's amnesty laws. If the court affirms the Federal Court ruling, the door will be open to further human rights prosecutions.

Read the press release at http://www.hrw.org/press/2001/12/argtrials1212.htm
Read the report at http://www.hrw.org/reports/2001/argentina/


BURUNDI

The transitional government of Burundi, installed November 1, inherited an eight-year-old civil war and an expanding and abusive "self-defense" program purportedly meant to protect civilians against rebel attack. The program includes the rural-based paramilitary "Guardians of the Peace" which have committed many killings, rapes, and other crimes over the last four years. HRW's report, "To Protect the People: The Government-sponsored 'self-defense' program in Burundi," documents cases of forced conscription, the use of child soldiers, and atrocities committed by the "Guardians of the Peace." The report calls on the government of Burundi, to disband the paramilitary force.
     Prior to the release of the report, authors Alison DesForges and Tony Tate presented advance copies to the Burundian Minister of Defense, and officials at the Belgian and US embassies, the US AID administrator in Burundi and the local UN representative.
     Alison also discussed the reports findings and recommendations with diplomats and officials in Brussels, New York, and Washington, and conducted radio interviews with the BBC, RFI, and VOA and with the two major private radio stations in Bujumbura which were broadcast repeatedly. The report was also covered by the New York Times. President Buyoya's remark that Human Rights Watch had a right to its opinion but would not dictate policy to his government was reported both locally and in the European press.

Read the press release at http://www.hrw.org/press/2001/12/Burundi1214.htm
En français: http://www.hrw.org/french/press/2001/burundi1213.htm

Read the report at http://www.hrw.org/reports/2001/burundi/
En français: http://www.hrw.org/french/reports/burundi2/
Order the report at http://store.yahoo.com/hrwpubs/burtoprotpeo.html


EGYPT

Saadeddin Ibrahim is one of Egypt's leading voices for political reform. A sociology professor at the American University in Cairo, he was the founder and director of the Ibn Khaldun Center for Development Studies until it was closed by the Egyptian government in June 2000. The Center's program, ranging from the protection of minority rights to civic empowerment, included voter registration campaigns and election monitoring. On May 21, 2001, Egypt's Supreme State Security Court sentenced Saadeddin Ibrahim to seven years in prison and six co-defendants to prison terms ranging from two to five years with labor.
     HRW's backgrounder, "The State of Egypt vs. Free Expression: The Ibn Khaldun Trial," was released on December 18, one day before the defendants' appeal was heard before the Court of Cassation. It concluded that the proceedings were unfair at all stages, criticized the state of emergency decrees under which some of the charges were brought, and condemned the treatment of the defendants at the time of their arrest and initial detention. Human Rights Watch believes the arrest and trials were politically motivated and that Saadeddin Ibrahim and others associated with the Ibn Khaldun Center were targeted because of their peaceful exercise of freedom of expression and criticism of the government.

Read the backgrounder at http://hrw.org/backgrounder/mena/egypt/index.htm


RWANDA

Although peace in the region is still a distant hope, both Rwandan government troops and rebel forces of the Army for the Liberation of Rwanda (ALIR) have given civilians greater protection in the conflict in Rwanda's northwest in 2001. In "Rwanda: Observing the Rules of War?" Human Rights Watch shows that both government and rebel forces imposed new rules restricting attacks on civilians in the internal conflict, enforcing these through disciplinary measures. In stark contrast, the new rules did not apply to fighting by the Rwandan army and its proxies in Congo's eastern Kivu region or to ALIR's forces there. ALIR forces inside Rwanda also persisted in past patterns of looting and the use of child soldiers.
     Researchers Alison DesForges and Sara Rakita discussed the contents of the report with representatives of the major embassies in Kigali. Internationally, Alison met with officials of the Belgian Foreign Ministry, the European Commission, the UK's Department for International Development, the US State Department, and the French Foreign Ministry and conducted interviews with VOA, RFI, and BBC. The Rwandan Foreign Minister denounced the report.

Read the press release at http://www.hrw.org/press/2001/12/rwanda1220.htm
Read the report at http://hrw.org/reports/2001/rwanda2/
Order the report at http://store.yahoo.com/hrwpubs/rwanobrulofw.html


NIGERIA

Between September 7 and 13, 2001, the city of Jos became the scene of mass killing and destruction for the first time in its history. As many as one thousand people are believed to have been killed in the six days of violence between Christians and Muslims. Thousands of houses and buildings were smashed or burnt; homes and businesses were looted; and some villages, such as Dilimi on the outskirts of Jos, were virtually razed. Government authorities and security forces failed to take action that could have saved hundreds of lives.
     HRW's report, "Jos: A City Torn Apart," describes the background to these events, highlighting clear warning signs of growing tension in the weeks before the violence. Several nongovernmental organizations directly approached state government, police and military authorities to warn of the impending dangers. Effective government action is urgently needed, HRW warned, if the violence in Jos, and in hot spots across the country, is not to flare up again and cause thousands of more deaths.

Read the press release online at http://www.hrw.org/press/2001/12/Nigeria1218.htm
Read the report at http://www.hrw.org/reports/2001/nigeria/
Order this report at http://store.yahoo.com/hrwpubs/nigjoscittor.html


------
BECOME A MEMBER OR MAKE A CONTRIBUTION

Your contribution to Human Rights Watch will allow us to continue to investigate human rights conditions in more than 70 countries and to generate pressure to end abuses. HRW does not accept financial support from any government or government agency. Every investigation we undertake, every advocacy campaign we embark on, and every report we produce is funded solely by generous private contributions.

To find out more about membership, or to make a donation online, by phone, or by postal mail, visit http://www.hrw.org/donations/

HRW Logo Contribute to Human Rights Watch

Home | About Us | News Releases | Publications | About HRW | Info by Country | Global Issues | Campaigns | Free Mailing Lists | Community | Store | Film Festival | Search | Site Map | Contact Us | Press Contacts | Privacy Policy

© Copyright 2006, Human Rights Watch    350 Fifth Avenue, 34th Floor    New York, NY 10118-3299    USA