










|
|
From the Village Voice
Material Witnesses
by Jessica Winter
Week of June 12-18, 2002
An itemized casualty list of
calamities across multiple nations,
The Trials of Henry Kissinger is
something of a microcosm of the
2002 Human Rights Watch festival itself. Condensing Christopher
Hitchens's enraged deposition into 80 lucid minutes, directors Alex Gibney
and Eugene Jarecki map out Kissinger's collusions with Nixon and Ford in
the short-circuiting of the '68 Paris peace talks, secret bombing of
Cambodia, upending of democracy in Chile, and savaging of East Timor.
The revered elder statesman becomes Machiavellian
tyrant-as-apparatchik, driven equally by chillingly abstract realpolitik and
panting power lust. Hitchens & co. sometimes press their case too hard
(as when they posit Kissinger as the virtual lone gunman who distended
the American war in Vietnam by four years) and remain hazy on the
logistics of charging him in international court. Quibbles aside, though,
Trials is an indispensable primer on U.S. foreign policy—especially during
wartime.
The series's weak fiction lineup includes Ken Loach's tepid if
characteristically heartfelt The Navigators, which examines the effects
of privatization on an ensemble of British Rail employees, and Chris Eyre's
follow-up to Smoke Signals, the unwieldy brotherly-love dramedy Skins.
For the more robust documentary slate, the theater of war is the main
stage. Week two offers several works about the Israeli-Palestinian
conflict (to be reviewed next issue), and opening night unveils the sequel
to last year's HRW standout Jung (War): In the Land of the Mujaheddin.
Fabrizio Lazzaretti and Alberto Vendemmiati's Afghanistan Year 1380
(unavailable for preview) returns to Kabul in mid September as the NGO
Emergency races to reopen their Taliban-shuttered hospital for wounded
civilians.
Two of the strongest movies on view are testimonies from the home
front. To record the use of rape as a military strategy, Lilibet Foster's
Operation Fine Girl travels to Sierra Leone to interview young women
used as sex slaves during their country's decade-long conflagration.
Good Husband, Dear Son camps out in a village near Sarajevo, where
four in five of the male residents were killed during the war in Bosnia.
Relatives recall their lost boys and linger over mementos: plastering
tools, items of clothing, a gradebook, a handprint. Heddy Honigmann's
doc shares a plangent material specificity—a kind, patient attention to
quotidian detail—with the Times's Portraits of Grief.
Broken blood ties are traced in Jaime
Camino's The Children of Russia, an oddly
static collection of interviews with the
now elderly children of anti-fascist
warriors sent to live in the Soviet Union
during the Spanish Civil War, and in Family
Fundamentals (also featured in the New
Festival), about the estranged gay
children of Biblical literalists. The
upheavals in Indonesia at the outset of
the post-Suharto reformasi are seen partly through the prism of one
voluble family in Leonard Retel Helmrich's superb verité doc The Eye of
the Day, while ferocious mother love is a driving force in Jon Osman and
Jonathan Stack's Justifiable Homicide, in which Giuliani voter Margarita
Rosario is reborn as a police-brutality activist following her son's 1995
death at the hands of the NYPD. The film incorporates choice footage of
an installment of the mayor's radio show: New Yorkers are invited to
refresh their pre-9-11 Rudy memories when he berates the dead boy's
mother, tells three discrete lies to his listeners over her protestations,
and then disconnects her.
The renowned photographer James Nachtwey is a one-man human rights
watch, journeying to the world's most forsaken corners to produce
eidetic mass-market images of cataclysm: genocide in Rwanda, famine in
Somalia and Sudan, war in Kosovo and the Palestinian territories. Much of
Christian Frei's War Photographer is given over to watching Nachtwey
silently at work while editors, an ex-girlfriend, and Christiane Amanpour
(playing Katrin Cartlidge in No Man's Land) praise his otherworldly calm
and steadfast reticence. For his part, Nachtwey speaks of his intentions
in bland, humble aphorisms, and hardly at all of his individual experiences.
The photographer's show-don't-tell stance is admirable, but it can make
him a problematic documentary subject. War Photographer infers the
psychological and physical toll of his peripatetic existence, but provides
scant insight into his technique—one that often results in incongruously
meticulous compositions of human degradation. Nachtwey's intrepid
activist motivations, however, are never in doubt, even if—as he
attests—he must constantly ask himself, "Do I make a living from other
people's suffering?"
|