September 6, 2006

Condemned Communities

Forced Evictions in Jakarta

I. Summary
Key Recommendations
II. Methods
III. Background
A Legacy of Evictions and Inadequate Access to Housing for the Poor
Infrastructure Development and the Role of International Agencies
Governor Sutiyoso's Campaign Against the Poor and Migrants
Public Order Officials
Urban Gangs Involved in Evictions
IV. Insecure Land Tenure
V. What is a "Forced Eviction"?
Legal Standards
Notice and Compensation Requirements in Indonesia
Justifications for Evictions Offered by the Jakarta government
VI. Violence and Excessive Use of Force
Excessive Use of Force Against Residents
Destruction and Loss of Personal Property
Government Use of Urban Gangs
Violence and Intimidation Against NGO Activists
VII. Lack of Consultation
Failure to Consult
Insufficient Notice
Discriminatory Impact of Notification Process on Women
VIII. Inadequate Compensation
Coercion and Lack of Consultation in the Compensation Process
No Compensation
Low Compensation
Compensation Reduced by Government
Corruption in the Compensation Process
Provision of Inadequate Alternative Land
IX. Consequences of Evictions
Effects of Evictions on Women and Girls
Effects of Evictions on Children
Effects of Evictions on Migrants
Inadequate Shelter Following Evictions
Cyclical Nature of Evictions
X. Detailed Recommendations101
To the Jakarta Regional Government101
To Both the Regional and National Governments104
To the National Government of Indonesia104
To International Donors106
To the Japan Bank for International Cooperation106
To Private Sector Developers, Construction Companies, Architectural Firms, and Others Involved in Building Projects in Indonesia107
To the United Nations107
Appendix 1: How to Submit an Objection to a JBIC Project108
Appendix 2: Links to Important Documents110
Acknowledgements111